Unit S55
NATURAL ARCH-CARNERO CREEK
High alpine terrain spanning the La Garita Wilderness with remote ridges and mountain passes.
Hunter's Brief
S55 is upper-elevation sheep country straddling the Continental Divide in south-central Colorado. Rolling to steep alpine terrain dominates, with scattered timber at lower elevations giving way to open tundra and rocky slopes above timberline. Access comes primarily from the north via Colorado 114 and east via U.S. 285, with limited but serviceable roads penetrating the unit from valleys below. Water is scarce—hunters rely on springs and seasonal runoff rather than perennial streams. The terrain is big enough and complex enough to offer solitude, but preparation and physical fitness are non-negotiable.
- Compact: under 200 sq mi
- Moderate: 200 - 800 sq mi
- Vast: over 800 sq mi
- Few: under 25%
- Some: 25 - 60%
- Most: over 60%
- Limited: under 0.7 mi/mi² (backcountry)
- Fair: 0.7 - 1.5 mi/mi²
- Connected: over 1.5 mi/mi² (well-roaded)
- Flat: under 20% mountains
- Rolling: 20 - 55%
- Steep: over 55%
- Sparse: under 20%
- Moderate: 20 - 50%
- Dense: over 50%
- Limited: under 0.3% area
- Moderate: 0.3 - 2% area
- Abundant: over 2% area
Terrain Deep Dive
Landmarks & Navigation
Cochetopa Pass (roughly 10,000 feet) is the dominant geographic feature, a major saddle and navigation landmark on the western side of the unit. Cathedral Rock and Devils Knob provide distinctive navigation reference points visible for glassing from distance. The La Garita Park complex—including Fullerton Park, Sunnyside Park, and La Garita Park itself—offers known openings for spotting sheep.
Moon Pass and Carnero Pass are secondary divides useful for orientation. Indian Head, Hat Mountain, and Storm King Mountain give hunters high vantage points for glassing long-range country. These summits serve as both navigation aids and potential glassing platforms.
Elevation & Habitat
The unit climbs from roughly 7,600 feet in the lower valleys to nearly 13,000 feet at alpine summits. Ponderosa and mixed conifer forests cover moderate portions of the middle elevations, particularly on north-facing slopes and in drainages, transitioning to aspen and sparse timber above 10,000 feet. Higher slopes open into alpine tundra, rocky outcrops, and sparse grass—classic bighorn sheep terrain.
The Continental Divide corridor runs along the western boundary, where exposed ridges and cliff-band systems provide escape terrain and natural travel corridors. Complexity comes from steep drainages cutting through rolling country.
Access & Pressure
Nearly 930 miles of roads exist across the unit, but most are low-grade county roads, Forest Service tracks, and ATV trails (including the La Garita Driveway). Major highway access is limited—U.S. 285 and Colorado 114 are the primary paved routes. This creates moderate accessibility that filters out casual hunters but remains feasible for well-prepared parties. The La Garita Wilderness boundary on the west creates a genuine backcountry zone accessible only on foot or horseback; most road access clusters on the eastern and northern approaches.
Pressure exists but concentrates on accessible entry points; off-road hunters and those willing to hike deeper find less competition.
Boundaries & Context
S55 encompasses the Natural Arch and Carnero Creek drainage system in Rio Grande and Saguache counties, anchored by the La Garita Wilderness boundary and Continental Divide on its west side. The unit sprawls across a transition zone between the San Juan Mountains' high peaks and the rolling plateau country to the east. Colorado 114 forms the northern boundary, U.S. 285 the eastern edge, and Colorado 112/U.S. 160 mark the southern limit.
Access towns include Del Norte and La Garita; the landscape transitions from ranched valleys at lower elevations to alpine backcountry above.
Water & Drainages
Water is limited and seasonal—this is critical to hunting strategy. South Fork Saguache Creek, Rincon Creek, and Moon Creek are the primary drainages, but flow decreases as summer progresses. Springs are scattered throughout: Sunday Spring, Ridge Spring, High Spring, Boland Spring, and Shaw Springs provide more reliable water access, though they require knowledge of location and seasonal reliability.
Hunters should scout springs early in the season or rely on seasonal runoff in the main drainages. The high elevation means snowmelt drives water availability in early season; later hunts require planned water access or willingness to move camps frequently.
Hunting Strategy
S55 is exclusively bighorn sheep country. The high alpine terrain, cliff bands, and rolling ridges provide classic sheep habitat; the Continental Divide corridor and upper park systems harbor sheep populations. Success depends on glassing from high vantage points—summits like Indian Head and Storm King Mountain allow hunters to see miles of escape terrain.
Early season means higher elevation snow may still limit access; later season brings sheep lower but also requires careful water planning. Physical fitness is essential; terrain complexity scores 7.7/10 because navigation, elevation gain, and weather exposure demand solid mountaineering skills. Approach from accessible valleys and work ridges methodically, staying alert for sheep in cliff systems and rocky outcrops.